New York City Files Lawsuit Against TikTok, Facebook, and YouTube Over Youth Mental Health Impact

New York City has filed a lawsuit against social media platforms, including TikTok, Instagram, Facebook, Snapchat, and YouTube. The lawsuit alleges that the designs of these platforms exploit the mental health of young users and cost the city US$100 million in related health programs and services every year.

Social Media Platform Impact on Youth Mental Health

The lawsuit contends that the platforms are accountable for a surge in mental health issues among young people, like depression and suicidal thoughts. According to New York City, these issues place a significant burden on mental health services provided by schools, public hospital systems, and municipalities.

The lawsuit comes after social media executives faced tough questions from lawmakers during the latest congressional hearings. Questions were raised over how their platforms may influence young users, particularly teenage girls, to harmful content, affecting their mental health and body image.

During a press conference, Mayor Eric Adams said, “NYC is the first major American city to take combined steps of this magnitude and call out the danger of social media clearly and directly, just as the surgeon general did with tobacco and guns.” He declared the city intends to seek monetary damages and equitable relief to fund prevention education and mental health treatment.

The city also designed a social media action plan that aims to hold platforms accountable, provide education and support to youth and families, and understand the long-term impacts of social media on youth.

Response from Social Media Platforms

A spokesperson from Snap highlighted the platform’s different design, which is focused on facilitating communication among close friends. Meta, the parent company of Instagram and Facebook, stressed its commitment to safety and support for young users. However, TikTok and YouTube have yet to respond to the allegations.

Mayor’s Concerns and Justification

Mayor Adams declared social media a “profound risk of harm,” a “public health hazard,” and an “environmental toxin” for kids. He asserted the increased impact on the lives of young people, stating, “Instead of talking to each other over lunch at the cafeteria, they are absorbed in screens,” he said. “Instead of playing at the park with friends, they are inside on a sunny day, clicking and scrolling. Instead of learning confidence and resilience, they’re being exposed to content that often leads to insecurity and depression.”

Despite the city’s initiative, legal challenges exist because of “Section 230”, which holds that tech companies cannot be held liable for the content users post to their platforms. In contrast, the EU’s Digital Services Act allows for substantial fines against companies that violate the law.

WRITTEN BY

Team Eela

TechEela, the Bedrock of MarTech and Innovation, is a Digital Media Publication Website. We see a lot around us that needs to be told, shared, and experienced, and that is exactly what we offer to you as shots. As we like to say, “Here’s to everything you ever thought you knew. To everything, you never thought you knew”